Papa Gallo  MexicanRestaurant


Gift Cards

To purchase an instant virtual gift card hit the button!

​​Fayetteville, NY

​​​​​Papa Gallo Take Out & How it works

Take Out is available for dinner only Tuesday-Thursday 4PM to 8:00 PM.

Friday -Saturday, 4PM to 8:45 PM.

We have resumed our online ordering, just click the ORDER ONLINE! button.

If it says that it is unavailable it means that we are experiencing a high volume and it needed to be suspended. Please try calling the restaurant if you are having difficulty ordering online.


For Phone in orders, please call the restaurant starting at 4PM, up to an hour before you wish to pickup your food. We will let you know an approximate time your food will be ready for curbside pickup.  

Our phone# is 315-632-4789

When you call please be ready with a credit card, a cell phone number and the make, model & color of the vehicle which will be used for pick up. Please come to the front door for pickup.  

Please note that promotions, discounts or coupons do not apply to take out.

***Food supply chains are not operating normally.  We will do our best to have the entire menu available***


          Chips & Salsa:  fried corn tortilla chips, house made chipotle spicy salsa & pico de gallo                                 $7
                                                     Large Guacamole $9           Poblano Cerveza Queso $7                 Tres Botana     $20

          Soups:    Bowl of our Chicken Tortilla with crisp tortilla strips & avacado or

                          Poblano Chowder, roasted poblano peppers, corn, potato, cream & cheddar cheese                        $8

          Nachos:  topped with choice of:  ground beef, pulled chicken, adobo pork, or shredded
                          beef, refried beans, house queso, jalapeños, pico de gallo, guacamole & seasoned sour cream       $18

          Flautas:   four chorizo sausage & Chihuahua cheese fried corn tortilla flutes                                                     $12

          Jerk Shrimp:  four grilled jerk marinated shrimp, jerk dipping sauce                                                                   $14


          Gallo Chicken Salad:  mixed greens with red onion, orange supremes, goat cheese,                                    $18 
            & a seasoned grilled & sliced 6oz chicken breast

          Jerk Chicken Salad: a bed of romaine lettuce, with black beans, pico de gallo, corn,                                      $18
            avocado & jerk marinated grilled & sliced 6oz chicken breast

          Jerk Shrimp Salad: a bed of romaine lettuce, with black beans, pico de gallo, corn,                                        $23
            avocado & four jerk marinated grilled shrimp.

         Taco Salad:  Crisp flour tortilla bowl, romaine lettuce, Spanish rice, pinto beans, pico de gallo,                        $16
            guacamole, seasoned sour cream, cheese blend & choice of: ground beef, adobo pork, chicken,
            shredded beef or vegetable medley

           Gallo or Jerk Salad without protein                                                                                                                $9

        Smothered Grande Burritos  

         Flour tortilla with meat, beans, rice & cheese, topped with house slaw & sour cream

          Tico:  ground beef or shredded barbacoa, topped with rojo sauce                                                                    $17

          Diablo:  adobo pork, habanero salsa, topped with jalapeños, & morita sauce (Hot!!!)                                      $17

          Verde:  pulled chicken topped with pico de gallo & verde sauce                                                                        $17

          Cowboy:  adobo pulled pork, borracho beans, rice, mixed cheese, morita sauce,                                           $17
            chipotle aioli & fried onion strings

          Pescado:  fried cat fish, verde sauce, pickled red onions & chipotle aioli (no sour cream)                             $18

         Camarón:  black beans, rice, queso fresco, sautéed shrimp, red onion, squash,
            baby tomatoes, morita sauce & tomatillo cream (no sour cream)                                                                    $18

          Veggie:  marinated crimini mushrooms, zucchini & cherry tomato, rice, refried beans,                                    $15
            Chihuahua cheese & choice of sauce

   Tacos, Quesadillas & Enchiladas  Served with Spanish rice & choice of beans

           Three soft flour tacos per order (hard shell and soft corn tortillas available)

          Pollo Verde:  pulled chicken in a verde sauce with a corn, black bean & red pepper salsa,                          $17
            topped with a mixed cheese blend

          Al Pastor:  braised adobo pork with onion & grilled pineapple, topped with queso fresco                               $17

          Barbacoa:  shredded smoked sirloin topped with spicy braised cabbage & queso fresco                             $17


          Carne Asada:  grilled Black Angus sirloin steak with pico de gallo, avocado & queso fresco                         $18

          Pescado:  fried mahi mahi house chipotle aioli, pickled red onions, shredded cabbage & cheese blend       $18

          Jerk Shrimp Tacos:  Jerk seasoned sauteed baby shrimp, house slaw, queso fresco, cilantro,

            pico de gallo, jerk vinaigrette                                                                                                                            $18

          Quesadillas:  flour tortilla with mixed cheese, pico de gallo, sour cream & choice of:                                    $17
            bean, chicken, ground beef, smoked sirloin, adobo pork, or vegetable medley

          Enchiladas: Three corn tortillas filled with cheese & choice of: ground beef, adobo pork,                              $17
            pulled chicken or smoked flank; choice of sauce, covered with melted mixed cheese blend

          Fajitas:  choice of seasoned flank, shrimp or chicken, sauteed with peppers & onions, served with

            flour tortillas, sour cream, pico de gallo, cheese & guacamole

                          Chicken  $18              Shrimp  $20                   Flank  $22            Shrimp & Steak  $25

          Our Homemade Sauces

          Rojo  a red sauce made with tomatoes, onions & spices Mild Heat

          Verde  a green sauce made with tomatillos, onions, & spices Tangy & Medium Heat

          Morita made with smoked roasted chilies, tomatoes, garlic, onions & cumin Hot & Smokey

          Tomatillo Cream our verde sauce blended with cream & white wine Mild to Medium Heat

          Queso Poblano ​cheese sauce made with cream, roasted poblano peppers & beer Medium to Mild Heat

          Kid's Menu

          Chicken Fingers:  Three breaded, then fried chicken tenders served with fries                                              $9

          Quesadilla:  Six inch round tortillas filled with cheese blend, with choice of chicken

           or ground beef, served with fries                                                                                                                        $9

          Kid's Tacos:  Two soft flour tacos with choice of chicken or ground beef, served with fries                            $9

Prices reflect a cash discount of 3.5%