​​​​​Papa Gallo Take Out & How it works

Take Out is available for dinner only Tuesday-Thursday 4PM to 8:00 PM.

Friday -Saturday, 4PM to 8:30 PM.

We have resumed our online ordering, just click the ORDER ONLINE! button.

If it says that it is unavailable it means that we are experiencing a high volume and it needed to be suspended. Please try calling the restaurant if you are having difficulty ordering online.


For Phone in orders, please call the restaurant starting at 4PM, up to an hour before you wish to pickup your food. We will let you know an approximate time your food will be ready for pickup.  

Our phone# is 315-632-4789

Please note that promotions, discounts or coupons do not apply to take out.

***Food supply chains are not operating normally.  We will do our best to have the entire menu available***

​​Fayetteville, NY

Papa Gallo  MexicanRestaurant


Gift Cards

To purchase an instant virtual gift card hit the button!



 Dishes with Ѵ are or Can Be Made vegetarian. Vegan options are also available.
 ƓƑ symbolizes that a dish is gluten free or CAN BE Made gluten free, please specify


 Chicken Tortilla Soup  crisp tortilla strips, fresh avocado, cilantro                                                                                $8 ƓƑ

 Poblano Chowder  roasted poblano peppers, corn, potato, cheddar cheese                                                                $8 V

 Chips & Salsa  fried corn tortilla chips, house made chipotle spicy salsa, pico de gallo                                                $8 VƓƑ

 Large Guacamole $10        Poblano Cerveza Queso $8           

 Tres Botana (Chips, Salsas, Guac & Queso)   $22 VƓƑ

  topped with choice of:  ground beef, pulled chicken, adobo pork, or shredded beef,
 refried beans, house queso, jalapeños, pico de gallo, guacamole, seasoned sour cream                                             $18 VƓƑ

 Ahi Tuna  chili dusted seared rare & sliced, over mixed greens with a pineapple salsa                                                 $15 ƓƑ

 Flautas  four chorizo sausage & Chihuahua cheese fried corn tortilla flutes                                                                   $12 ƓƑ

 Empanada  three deep fried pastries filled with spinach, white onion & goat cheese, topped with
 queso fresco, rojo & verde sauces                                                                                                                                    $12 V

 Jerk Shrimp  four grilled jerk marinated shrimp, jerk dipping sauce                                                                                $15 ƓƑ



 Gallo Salad  mixed greens, red onions, candied pecans, orange supremes, goat cheese                                            $9 VƓƑ

 Jerk Salad  a bed of romaine lettuce, with black beans, pico de gallo, corn, avocado                                                    $9 VƓƑ

 Add to salad:  Jerk Chicken $10    Five Grilled Shrimp $15

 Ahi Tuna Salad  chili dusted seared sushi grade tuna, mixed greens, tamarind vinaigrette &
 a pineapple salsa                                                                                                                                                               $17 VƓƑ

 Taco Salad  Crisp flour tortilla bowl, romaine lettuce, Spanish rice, refried beans, pico de gallo,

 guacamole, seasoned sour cream, cheese blend & choice of: ground beef, adobo pork, chicken,
 shredded beef or vegetable medley                                                                                                                                   $17 VƓƑ

 Smothered Grande Burritos  Can be made Chimichanga Style (deep fried) or as a Burrito Bowl
 Flour tortilla, meat, beans, rice, cheese, house slaw & sour cream
 Add a side of rice & beans for $4

 Tico  shredded beef or ground beef topped with rojo sauce                                                                                             $17 ƓƑ

 Diablo  adobo pork, habanero salsa, topped with jalapeños, & morita sauce (Hot!!!)                                                     $17 ƓƑ

 Verde  pulled chicken topped with pico de gallo, verde sauce                                                                                          $17 ƓƑ

 Cowboy  adobo pulled pork, borracho beans, rice, mixed cheese, morita sauce,                                                           $17 ƓƑ
 chipotle aioli, fried onions

 Birria  braised black angus steak & short ribs, borracho brans, rice, cheese, house queso, morita sauce,

 house pickled jalepenos                                                                                                                                                     $18 ƓƑ

Pescado  fried cat fish, verde sauce, pickled red onion, chipotle aioli (no sour cream)                                                     $18

 Camarón  black beans, rice, queso fresco, sautéed shrimp, onion, zuccini,
 baby tomatoes, morita sauce, tomatillo cream (no sour cream)                                                                                       $18 ƓƑ

 Veggie  marinated crimini mushrooms, zucchini, cherry tomato, rice, refried beans,                                                      $16 ƓƑ
 Chihuahua cheese & choice of sauce


 Our House Made Sauces

 Verde  a green sauce, made with tomatillos, onions & spices, medium heat VƓƑ

 Rojo  a red sauce made with, tomatoes, onions & spices, mild heat VƓƑ

 Tomatillo Cream  our verde sauce blended with cream & white wine, medium to mild heat Ѵ

 Queso Poblano  a cheese sauce made with mixed cheeses, poblano peppers, beer & cream, mild heat Ѵ

 Morita  smoked roasted chilies, tomatoes, garlic, onions & cumin, medium to hot VƓƑ


 Bean Choices

 Borracho Beans 
mixture of black & kidney beans cooked with beer, bacon & vegetables

 Refried Beans  blended pinto beans cooked with veggies & veggie stock ѴƓƑ

 Black Beans  cooked with veggies & spices ѴƓƑ  


 Taco Dinners 
 Served with Spanish rice & choice of beans (3 soft flour tortilla tacos per order)

 Pollo Verde Tacos  pulled verde chicken, corn, black bean, red pepper salsa, mixed cheese blend                             $17 ƓƑ

 Al Pastor Tacos  slow roasted adobo pork with grilled pineapple salsa, chihuahua cheese                                           $17 ƓƑ

 Barbacoa Tacos  seasoned braised beef, cabbage slaw, queso fresco                                                                         $17 ƓƑ

 Carne Asada Tacos  seasoned flank steak with pico de gallo, avocado, queso fresco                                                  $18 ƓƑ

 Birria Tacos  braised black angus steak & short ribs, pan fried corn tortillas, melted cheese, onion, cilantro,

 braising dipping saucce                                                                                                                                                     $18  ƓƑ

 Pescado Tacos  fried cat fish, chipotle aioli, shredded cabbage, pickled red onion, cheese blend                                $18

 Jerk Shrimp Tacos  jerk seasoned sautéed baby shrimp, house slaw, queso fresco, fresh cilantro,
 pico de gallo, jerk vinaigrette                                                                                                                                              $18 ƓƑ



 Chihuahua Chicken  grilled chicken breast, sauteed red onions, crimini mushrooms,
 Chihuahua cheese, romaine, pico de gallo & chipotle aioli, fries & spicy ketchup                                                           $17 ƓƑ

 Nacho Burger  grilled 8oz burger, Monterey jack & cheddar cheeses,
 fried tortilla strips, sour cream, guacamole, pico de gallo & jalapenos, fries & spicy ketchup                                         $17 ƓƑ

 Fajita Wrap  choice of seasoned flank, chicken or baby shrimp sautéed with peppers & onions,
 wrapped in a flour tortilla, served with Spanish rice & choice of beans                                                                            $18 ƓƑ


 El Plato Principal

 Chile Relleno  roasted poblano chile stuffed with black beans, corn, cheese blend, flash fried,
 topped with rojo sauce, queso poblano & queso fresco                                                                                                  $17 V

 Quesadillas  flour tortilla with mixed cheese, pico de gallo, sour cream & choice of:                                                   $17 V
 bean, chicken, ground beef, shredded beef, adobo pork, or vegetable medley

 Enchiladas  Three corn tortillas filled with cheese & choice of: ground beef, adobo pork,                                            $17 VƓƑ
 pulled chicken or shredded beef; choice of sauce, covered with melted mixed cheese blend

 Fajitas  seasoned steak, shrimp, or chicken sautéed with peppers, onions, lime scallion salsa,
 served with flour tortillas, sour cream, pico de gallo, guacamole, cheese blend  VƓƑ

 Chicken  $18          Shrimp  $20          Flank Steak   $22

 El Postre

 Churros  Lightly fried pastry fingers dusted with sugar & cinnamon.  Served with Mexican
 chocolate sauce & vanilla ice cream                                                                                                                             $9

 Churro Ice Cream Sandwich  Lightly fried churro batter sandwiched with vanilla ice cream,
 topped with chocolate sauce, whipped cream & berries                                                                                              $9

 Fried Ice Cream  Flash vanilla ice cream rolled in graham cracker & corn flakes. Topped with
 a choice of Mexican chocolate sauce, apple blossom honey, caramel, or a mixed berry sauce                                $9

 Vanilla Flan  Traditional Mexican custard made with vanilla beans, house made caramel,

 served with mixed berry coulis & fresh berries                                                                                                            $9

 Key Lime Pie Fresh Lime juice, sweetened condensed milk, graham cracker crust,

 whipped cream & berries                                                                                                                                             $9